Sep 10 2008
Secret Faith: Harry and Frodo? Meet Jesus.
It’s time for me to be unabashedly honest here: I’m a Christian. A convicted Christian. I’m not one to hide from my faith, although I’m also not one to hide from the truth that I’m nothing but a wretched sinner. I am, really. Only God knows.
But I also want to be clear that I’m not a ‘preacher’. And I don’t mean ‘preacher’ as in the recognized, devoted, qualified and educated pastor, priest or reverend. Those true kinds have their special gifts, and I always admire them. In fact, one of my best friends is a pastor.
When I say, ‘preacher’, I mean someone who constantly believes that there’s a message he or she needs to ‘preach’ because he or she has a right to and that everyone should listen. Their intention is to try and change minds. Their motives are really to try and communicate God. Instead of sharing Him. There’s a big difference.
In my everyday thoughts and inner rantings, I’ve remembered constant discussions and conflicts between topics such as the sacrilege of witchcraft and such in the Harry Potter books and whether or not Rowling is a satanist or if Tolkien worshipped Baal with his feces and urine or other such retarded stories (I exaggerate, of course. The latter story really doesn’t exist!). “Kids shouldn’t read Rowling, blah blah, yadda yadda,” and the same goes for the religious rite and its criticism of Pullman and HIS DARK MATERIALS, his fantasy series, the religious rite claiming it to be an attack on the church.
Read the books. Read them. And while you’re at it, try and pick up these particular books, too–
WALKING WITH FRODO by Sarah Arthur.
FINDING GOD IN THE LORD OF THE RINGS by Kurt Bruner and Jim Ware.
LOOKING FOR GOD IN HARRY POTTER by John Granger.
GOD, THE DEVIL, AND HARRY POTTER by John Killinger.
A little shocking, maybe? Maybe a little. There are actually more works of literature out there regarding the connections between Christianity and the novels some of us like to tear apart for their ’sacrilege’. But let me get to the point here.
This isn’t about proving whether or not the arguments in these books hold water. No. It’s not about whether or not we should or shouldn’t read this or that book because of this or that and that this person is wrong about this book or that book or right about this book or that book.
Yes, Philip Pullman is an atheist. But let’s make one thing clear (without getting too theological here): Christ himself actually ‘attacked’ the church, too. Christ himself abolished the old laws. Christ himself overturned tables, called leaders of the church a ‘brood of vipers’. I’m willing to bet, without a doubt, whether Pullman liked it or not, HIS DARK MATERIALS actually supports the truth about faith, the truth about how God wants us to be. God doesn’t want us to conform to a ‘religion’. God wants us to love one another and be holy people. The imagery, the words, the religious traditions–nothing, absolutely nothing, they are. Our faith comes from within, not in buildings and not in conformity. Not in judging others for being ‘unholy’ or ‘immoral’. Whether you like it or not, Pullman, you shout for us Christians. Even if you’re an atheist. Kind of pleasantly ironic and wonderful, I think. And in my opinion, as an atheist, you should be flattered.
That brings me to my point.
Really, how can we be sure that any of those wonderful authors actually do intend to ‘preach’ any kind of message in their fiction? C.S. Lewis doesn’t count. The man was a veritable theologian himself; so it remains easy to see the obvious allegory in THE CHRONICLES OF NARNIA. But what about J.K. Rowling? Can we judge what her intentions were? Can we judge what J.R.R. Tolkien’s intentions were? Do we really know? Can we really find the truth of what they really believe? Does it matter what they believe in? Just as in my previous point: Pullman’s an atheist, yet I can say without fear that HIS DARK MATERIALS could actually support true Christianity. Yes, I said it. Watch all the stones come my way.
In writing THE CAIN LETTERS and then also CHIMERA FALLS, the sequel, I completely knew what I wanted to write about. I wanted it to be about Christianity. But for those of you who have read my manuscripts, it’s pretty safe to say that they’re not ‘Christian’ books! I’d actually be surprised, if and when I get published, to find the books in a Christian bookstore. Dear, God, wow…. I mean, the books are about vampires, people! Urban fantasy. Urban fantasy + Christianity = usually not a common mix of themes to then categorize it as acceptable “Christian” fiction.
I didn’t intend for my work to have any kind of message. But they do. There’s a Christian message there. That doesn’t mean I intended it. That doesn’t mean I woke up one day and thought, “I’m going to preach to the world the wonders of God through this book, and many will come to know Him.” No. I simply wanted to write a book. An entertaining book. Because of an inner faith, a secret faith, no matter what, in anything you write, it becomes a part of your words. Your experiences, your faith, your morals. Everything. It automatically becomes a part of it. That’s not preaching. That’s being.
I guess you can say I’m sharing my faith. But only because it’s important to me. It’s real to me. Not because I think it’s right. It’s not my place to judge. And that’s the point I’m making.
We don’t know if Rowling woke up one day and wanted to tell the world that God is right and everyone’s wrong. We certainly don’t know if Rowling wanted kids to worship the devil either. We’ll probably never know what Tolkien’s intention was (although I believe he was good friends with C.S. Lewis back in the day).
I’m betting that their intentions were simply to write something they loved. And when you love what you write, everything that you are gets poured into it. Whether you like it or not.
All this talk about, well, they’re communicating this message and that message. I then wonder if Rowling herself is shaking her head, smiling, thinking simply this–
I just had a character in my head (little Harry Potter), and I wanted to write a story about him. Here’s his story. Whatever else you get out of his story, well…let’s just say you have every right to and should make your own judgments.
Here, here, Rowling. I’m right there with you.








