Jan 04 2009
Premise Versus Plot
I love getting questions from friends about writing and the literary industry and stuff like that. It makes me feel special
.
This is one particular question that I need to address–fundamentally something interesting about us writers in general. I believe agent Nathan Bransford once touched on this topic a little bit. I don’t have the actual post; but believe you me, searching for it on his blog is about as easy as pie or cake or cannoli or just about any sweet and tasty dessert.
I have a friend who inquires constantly about novel writing. And I enjoy elaborating on many issues involving such a procedure. Said friend also has plenty of ideas for projects but, quite frankly, doesn’t think he or she has either the patience or maybe even the confidence to actually translate those ideas into full-fledged plots, leading toward completed, polished novels.
Now I’m going to be honest with you here: I enjoy projects. I have about…lemme see…four projects. One of them is VERMILION EYE, as you know. I also have about maybe a DOZEN other thoughts for possible projects. Actually, at this stage of development, they’d be called…premises.
So to make a long explanation less arduously long-winded, I enjoy new ideas for new books to write, especially if other people pitch them to me.
My friend had a basic premise. Said friend had a main character sort of fleshed out. Imagery was set in concrete. What was funny was how long it took for my friend to develop that. Not laugh-out-loud funny, mind you–I won’t ever laugh at anyone’s endeavor toward writing. What was funny was how my friend thought that it was SO difficult getting past that ’stage’ of writing.
The birth of an idea. A premise.
After my friend laid it out for me, I nodded my head. I processed it. The wheels in my head started turning. I love it when I get that way, by the way. It’s a beautiful thing.
My friend’s question was this: “Is there anything else you need as far as this ’story’? Is that the hard part?”
I had to be honest. No. Not at all.
At least not for me.
And ‘hard’ isn’t the operative word either.
My friend rolled his/her head back in astonishment; developing his/her ‘premise’ took about two weeks of brainstorming. I, in fact, was astonished at that.
Here’s a very simple example of what I mean by ‘premise’. The easy part. At least for me–
A grocery store clerk learns that he has the power to magically stock all the shelves in the store with a limitless supply of tampons, leaving the business without any need for rainchecks.
That would be a ‘premise’.
In my opinion, that’s easy. That premise (which now that I look at it, looks amusing) came about in my head literally in the time it took you to read it. Which would be about 20 seconds, probably.
The ‘hard’ part is the WHY…the HOW…the WHERE…the WHO. The ‘hard’ part is the CONFLICT, the actual PLOT.
My questions would be:
Who is this grocery store clerk? Where did he get this power from? Why does he have this power? What happens when the store runs out of room for tampons? Does he have a girlfriend who is in need of tampons? Does the female manager need tampons? Will tampons start growing out of his ass? What is the grocery store clerk’s mother’s name? Does he have a dog? Does he have a cat? What’s the name of the grocery store? Will he lose his power at the end? Will the store then need rainchecks again? Will all the women in the world suddenly lose the need for tampons and somehow magically dematerialize their used tampons by meditating on it?
I could go on and on and on and on and on and on.
And on.
I guess an easier way of describing this, is a ‘premise’ is basically what the project is about….
A ‘plot’ or ’story’ is how it happens.
How it happens is important to know. And it takes time. It takes a LOT of development. That’s why I say that ‘hard’ really isn’t the operative word. It’s not ‘hard’. It’s just time-consuming (which as you know I don’t have a whole lot of time these days).
To be honest, I thrive on plotting almost as much as actually writing the work. It gets my juices flowing. Here’s the point I need to make–for anyone who’s so interested in writing, like my friend who’s pitched this idea to me–
You need more than a ‘premise’.
So get ready to work.
Getting the idea is a beautiful thing. Making it live and breathe makes that beauty last. Trust me when I say that it’s grueling, too. When anyone writes their first novel, it’s a MAJOR task. Some may say it’s a lot of blood, sweat and tears. Sleepless nights.
So don’t stop at the ‘premise’, thinking you’re set and you can sit at the computer, thinking the words’ll come out. Take some more notes. Some people outline (me). Others summarize, set up playlists, sketch characters in detail (Sarah Jensen, possibly the radiant H.L. Dyer, maybe Mary Lindsey, Scott Tracey, Michelle Mclean, yes, I’m talkin’ about all o’ you!).
It doesn’t matter what you do–just develop your premise into a plot. Understand what you want to write first. Understand where you want to go. Then go.
Where you’ll end up will get you giddy. I guarantee it. So to conclude my “unforgivable ranting”…. Happy writing, people. Enjoy your words. Have patience. And I promise a whole chorus of angels will sing “Alleluia” when you write the last word of your novel. Trust me. I heard the chorus back then.
And it was B-E-A-utiful.










